7 Minute Read

Metal Building vs. Pole Barn vs. Stick Built: Which is Right for You?

When it comes to choosing a structure for your property, the options can feel overwhelming. Should you go with a metal building, a pole barn, a stick-built garage, or a steel-framed structure? Each option has its pros and cons, and the right choice depends on your needs, budget, and long-term goals.

At The Carport Co., we specialize in durable, customizable metal buildings that offer unmatched value and performance. In this article, we’ll break down the key differences between these structures to help you make an informed decision. Want a price on a metal building that will last a lifetime? Visit our Get a Quote page.

Get Started

It’s quick and easy! Get a quote for an engineer stamped carport. Financing and rent-to-own options are available!

Landing Page Form
American flag icon to showcase our carports, garages, sheds, and commercial structures and manufactured in the United States of America

Manufactured in the United States

Photo of security symbol to showcase the security you experience when shopping with The Carport Co, as we offer a 20 year warranty on select structures

Competitive Warranties

Photo of construction worker to showcase our installation crews are licensed and insured, and will provide you with an excellent structure.

Licensed and Insured Installers

Icon of customer service representative to showcase The Carport Co's great customer service.

Outstanding Customer Service

Structures That Stand Strong™

Prefabricated metal (steel) building that was constructed to be a barndominium, which is essentially a house + garage + living space in one.

What is a Metal Building

Before we get into comparing and contrasting metal buildings and their alternatives, we must first discuss what a metal building actually is.

A metal building is a durable structure made from prefabricated tubing, designed to provide long lasting protection for vehicles, equipment, and belongings. At The Carport Co., our metal buildings are crafted from galvanized steel, available in both 14-gauge and 12-gauge for added strength and durability.

Benefits of Metal Buildings

The market share of metal buildings has exploded in the last 25 years. They have never been more popular. There are various benefits to choosing one over other solutions. Here are 5 of the biggest reasons customers choose metal buildings over alternative solutions:

1. Durability

Metal buildings are built to last. Made from galvanized steel, they are resistant to rust, corrosion, pests, and fire. Unlike wood or other materials, steel won’t warp, crack, or rot over time. This makes metal buildings an excellent choice for areas with harsh weather conditions, including high winds, heavy snow, and intense sunlight.

2. Affordability

When compared to traditional stick-built structures or pole barns, metal buildings offer significant cost savings. Their pre-engineered design reduces construction time and labor costs, while their low maintenance requirements save you money in the long run. Plus, with The Carport Co., you get FREE delivery and installation, making your investment even more affordable.

3. Customization

One of the biggest advantages of metal buildings is their versatility. At The Carport Co., we offer fully customizable options to meet your specific needs. Choose from a variety of:

  • Sizes: From compact carports to spacious metal buildings.

  • Styles: Classic, boxed-eave, or vertical roof designs.

  • Features: Add side panels, roll-up doors, windows, or insulation for enhanced functionality.

4. Quick Installation

Thanks to their pre-engineered design, metal buildings can be installed in a fraction of the time it takes to build a traditional structure. Most of our buildings are ready for use within days, not weeks or months. This means less disruption to your daily life and faster access to your new space.

5. Low Maintainence

Unlike wood or other materials, metal requires minimal upkeep. A simple rinse with water is often all that’s needed to keep your building looking like new. This saves you time, effort, and money on repairs and maintenance over the years.

Pole barn with red siding and metal siding and gray two-tone wainscotting. The front gable of the pole barn has a smaller gable off of it to act as a covered porch.

Metal Building vs. Pole Barn

Pole barns are traditional structures supported by wooden poles or posts buried in the ground. They’re often used for agricultural purposes, storage, or workshops. Here are a few key differences:

1. Durabiliity

  • Metal Buildings: Made from galvanized steel, our metal buildings are resistant to rust, corrosion, and pests. They’re built to last for decades with minimal maintenance.

  • Pole Barns: Wooden poles are susceptible to rot, termites, and weather damage, requiring regular upkeep.

2. Cost

  • Metal Buildings: The initial cost of purchasing a metal building is usually much lower, and metal buildings offer better long-term value due to their durability and low maintenance.

  • Pole Barns: Higher upfront cost, and higher maintenance expenses over time.

3. Customization

  • Metal Buildings: Fully customizable in size, style, and color. Add features like insulation, windows, or roll-up doors.

  • Pole Barns: Limited customization options compared to metal buildings.

Winner: Metal Buildings

Stick built garage with attic. The siding is covered with some kind of OSB or plywood. Stick build garages are typically much more expensive than metal buildings.

Metal Building vs. Stick Built

Stick-built structures are traditional buildings constructed on-site using wooden frames. They’re commonly used for homes, garages, and sheds.

1. Construction Time

  • Metal Buildings: Pre-engineered and quick to assemble. Most structures can be installed in days.

  • Stick Built: Time-consuming construction process, often taking weeks or months.

2. Strength and Durability

  • Metal Buildings: Steel frames provide superior strength and resistance to fire, wind, and pests.

  • Stick Built: Wooden frames are weaker and more vulnerable to fire, termites, and weather damage.

3. Cost

  • Metal Buildings: More cost-effective in the long run due to lower maintenance and longer lifespan.

  • Stick Built: Higher upfront and long-term costs due to labor and maintenance.

Winner: Metal Buildings

The Carport Company—metal buildings & carports company logo. The Carport Co. is an authorized dealer for several respected manufacturers in the pre-ngineered tube steel space.

Why Choose The Carport Co. for Your Metal Building

At The Carport Co., we’re committed to providing carports that are not only affordable but also built to last. Here’s why our customers trust us:

  • FREE Delivery and Installation: We handle the entire process, so you don’t have to worry about a thing.

  • Nationwide Coverage: We serve the majority of the United States, bringing durable carports to your doorstep (or driveway).

  • Premium Materials: Our metal buildings are made from prefabricated tube steel (galvanized steel), available in both 14-gauge and 12-gauge for added strength and durability.

  • Expert Guidance: Our team is here to help you every step of the way, from choosing the right structure to installation.

Frequently Asked Questions

A metal building is made from prefabricated tube steel, offering superior durability, customization, and low maintenance. A pole barn is a traditional structure supported by wooden poles, which are more susceptible to rot, pests, and weather damage. Metal buildings are generally more cost-effective in the long run due to their longevity and minimal upkeep.

Yes! Metal buildings are made from galvanized steel, which is stronger and more durable than the wooden frames used in stick-built structures. Steel is resistant to fire, wind, pests, and corrosion, making it a better choice for long-term use.

Thanks to their pre-engineered design, metal buildings can be installed in just a few days. This is significantly faster than stick-built structures, which can take weeks or even months to complete.

Absolutely! At The Carport Co., we offer fully customizable metal buildings. You can choose the size, style, color, and additional features like side panels, roll-up doors, windows, or insulation to create the perfect structure for your needs.

No, the upfront cost of a metal building is typically less than that of a pole barn or stick built structure. Additionally, you will save money on maintenance and upkeep over time, as metal buildings require very little maintenance.

Yes! Our metal buildings are engineered to withstand high winds, heavy snow, and other extreme weather conditions. They are built to meet or exceed local building codes, ensuring they provide reliable protection for years to come.

No, one of the biggest advantages of metal buildings is their low maintenance requirements. A simple rinse with water is often all that’s needed to keep your building looking like new. Unlike wood, steel won’t warp, crack, or rot over time.

Carports can withstand some tornados, but generally only those where the maximum wind speed reaches below 170 MPH. If your area frequently sees tornadoes with high wind speeds, consider investing in a storm-rated garage or reinforced metal building for maximum protection.

Yes, we offer both financing and rent-to-own options for our metal buildings. Give us a call at (888) 293-5588 or email [email protected] to learn more.

Yes, you will typically need a permit to install a metal building or carport in most areas. Exceptions are made for agricultural buildings. We have a separate article you may find helpful: Do You Need a Permit for a Metal Carport?

Ready to Begin Your Project?

Do you think The Carport Co. would be a good fit for you? We’d love to earn your business. Fill out the quote form, and one of our friendly representatives will be in touch with you shortly. We’re here to answer questions you may have, provide personalized recommendations, and get you an estimate on your project.

To speak with someone, call (888) 293-5588 or email [email protected].

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to enhance your property with a durable, versatile, and visually appealing metal structure. Contact The Carport Co. today and experience what we can do.

Visit our 3D Builder to design your own structure!

The Carport Company—metal buildings & carports company logo. The Carport Co. is an authorized dealer for several respected manufacturers in the pre-ngineered tube steel space.

Get Your FREE Custom Quote

No-obligation, 100% FREE quote, delivered in minutes.

Get Quote

The Ultimate Buyer’s Guide is a collection of articles by The Carport Co. These articles have been catered to first time steel and metal carport, garage, and commercial building buyers. Our goal is to share as much information with customers as possible, to help make informed decisions, and ensure a customer doesn’t discover an addition they would have liked to added at the time of sale, but was not aware of the option’s existence. 

Here is a preview of a few articles. To view the full Buyer’s Guide, please visit the Ultimate Buyer’s Guide page.